NEWS TALK RADIO Our Hosts
Powered by: Townhall.com
Sign Up
Thursday, July 02, 2009
Ann Coulter :: Townhall.com Columnist
So Much for Wise Latinas
by Ann Coulter
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Should Eric Holder be confirmed for Attorney General?

With the Supreme Court's decision in Ricci v. DeStefano this week, we can now report that Sonia Sotomayor is even crazier than Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

To recap the famous Ricci case, in 2003, the city of New Haven threw out the results of a firefighters' test -- which had been expressly designed to be race-neutral -- because only whites and Hispanics scored high enough to receive immediate promotions, whereas blacks who took the test did well enough only to be eligible for promotions down the line.

Inasmuch as the high-scoring white and Hispanic firemen were denied promotions solely because of their race, they sued the city for race discrimination.

Obama's Justice-designate Sotomayor threw out their lawsuit in a sneaky, unsigned opinion -- the judicial equivalent of "talk to the hand." She upheld the city's race discrimination against white and Hispanic firemen on the grounds that the test had a "disparate impact" on blacks, meaning that it failed to promote some magical percentage of blacks.

This strict quota regime was dressed up by the city -- and by Sotomayor's opinion -- as a reasonable reaction to the threat of lawsuits by blacks who were not promoted.

That's a complicated way of saying: Racial quotas are peachy.

According to Sotomayor, any test that gets the numbers wrong -- whatever "wrong" means in any given context of professions, populations, applicants, workers, etc. -- is grounds for a lawsuit, which in turn, is grounds for an employer to engage in race discrimination against disfavored racial groups, such as white men.

Consequently, the only legal avenue available to employers under Sotomayor's ruling is always to impose strict racial quotas in making hiring and promotion decisions.

Say, if the threat of a lawsuit permits the government to ignore the Constitution, can pro-lifers get New Haven to shut down all abortion clinics by threatening to sue them? There's no question but that abortion clinics have a "disparate impact" on black babies.

This week, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 for the white and Hispanic firefighters, overturning Sotomayor's endorsement of racial quotas.

But all nine justices rejected Sotomayor's holding that different test results alone give the government a green light to engage in race discrimination. Even Justice Ginsburg's opinion for the dissent clearly stated that "an employer could not cast aside a selection method based on a statistical disparity alone."

Indeed, the dissenters argued that the case should be returned to the lower courts to look for some hidden racial bias in the test. For Sotomayor, the results alone proved racial bias.

The one advantage Sotomayor's talk-to-the-hand opinion has over Justice Ginsburg's prolix dissent is that brevity prevented Sotomayor from having to explain why quotas aren't quotas.

That was left to Ginsburg.

Liberals desperately want race quotas -- as long as quotas never come to their offices.

But they can't say that, so instead they talk in circles for 10 hours straight, until everyone else is exhausted, and then, when no one is paying attention, they announce: So we're all agreed -- we will have racial quotas.

Based on her lifetime of experience working as a firefighter, Ginsburg said: "Relying heavily on written tests to select fire officers is a questionable practice, to say the least." Liberals prefer a more objective test, such as race.

Isn't excelling on written tests how Ruth Bader Ginsburg got where she is? It's curious how people whose entire careers are based on doing well on tests find them so irrelevant to other people's jobs.

In the middle of a fire, it can either be a great idea or the worst possible idea to open a door. An excellent method for finding out if your next fire chief knows the correct answer is a written test.

Unleashing the canard of all race-obsessed liberals, Ginsburg observed that courts have found that a fire officer's job "involves complex behaviors, good interpersonal skills, the ability to make decisions under tremendous pressure, and a host of other abilities -- none of which is easily measured by a written, multiple choice test."

So does a lawyer's job. And yet attorneys with absolutely no "interpersonal skills" get cushy jobs and extravagant salaries on the basis of their commendable performance on all manner of written tests, from multiple choice LSATs and bar exams to written law school exams.

I note that Ginsburg has not shown any particular interest in rectifying the "disparate impact" of legal exams: She never hired a single black law clerk out of the dozens she employed in more than a decade as an appeals court judge. (Her hiring practices on the Supreme Court are a state secret, but I can state with supreme certainty that her clerks do not reflect the racial mix of Washington, D.C.)

But liberals think other people's jobs are a joke, so the testing must also be a joke. That is -- other than their preferred test: "Is the applicant black, female or otherwise handicapped?"

There is no test that can prove all things about an employee and so there is no test that can't be derided by the race-mongers. Which is exactly the point. Get rid of all tests -- except for lawyers who graduated at the top of their law school classes at Columbia, like Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Then liberals are free to impose racial quotas on other people's jobs without limit.

As crazy as this is, even Ginsburg and the other dissenters made a big point of pretending there was some flaw in this particular test. None adopted Sotomayor's position that unequal test results alone prove discrimination.

This suggests that a wise Jewess, due to the richness of her life experiences, might come to a better judgment than a Latina judge would.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Ann Coulter is a columnist and author of Guilty: Liberal Victims and Their Assault On America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Ann Coulter and Townhall.com's daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
The wise Latina
Since she told us she's a wise Latina I figured she'd be approved.It's a good thing she told us that, otherwise I'd have thought she was just another Liberal racist with a bill of goods that smelled of BS.

wise Latinas
Since she told us she's a wise Latina I figured she'd be approved.It's a good thing she told us that, otherwise I'd have thought she was just another Liberal racist with a bill of goods that smelled of BS.

Not that anyone will read this a week
late.
But what the heck.

Helen, Jeb can bend over and kiss his own asz he is bearing for the Reconquista La Raza (THE RACE) crowd.

Mexicans ain't gonna vote to keep their kin folk in the hell hole THEY'VE made out of Meh he ko, and they ain't going to vote to send their own greasybacked selves back either. Ergo neither the RINOs or the CINOs much LESS the Real Reaganite Constitutional Conservationists are EVER going to get the Greasyback Reconquista Race vote. EVER! We cut off our own manhoods by even TRYING.

Tell them to go to Hell. By the next National Election the Country will be so gotohell MAD at the ruined economy and botched Treasonous Foreign Policy the Greasybacked Reconquista Racists will be running for the border in sheer terror anyway because they will KNOW they are likely targets of an Enraged Nation's Just Wrath!

mick

mick

So much for wise Latinas
Good title!! We're going crazy as a country -- logic seems to be spiraling down. It seems the dems can rhetoric their way through anything and their dumb constituents will believe anything.

Hispanics
Jeb Bush worries that the Republicans can never get the Hispanic vote, and that will keep us from winning in 2012. Having Soto Mayor voted onto Supreme Court will help the Democrats even more.

Souter or Sotomayor
Sotomayor's credentials, degrees, etc are not an issue. She has the paper work. The credentials do not make her a good judge. They only give her 'gravitas'.

The problem is her how she views the role of a judge. She says she will make decisions on the basis of her ethnicity and empathy. WOW! She does not say she gives priority to the law.

We are getting a substitute for Souter. Is she any improvement over Souter?


Sotomayor has empathy agenda
When one reads Sotomayor's statements you can see she endorses using empathy in making decisions.

The people in front of her are not treated equally. One side gets empathy the other doesn't.

Quotas are quotas
What don't people understand about 'quotas' . The test was rejected because only 'hispanics' and 'whites' scored high enough to qualify for promotion. This says the quota for blacks wasn't met.

Ann's comments don't change the facts.

A keen intellect.
Now she can judge all Hispanic women's intelligence based on the performance of one said same woman. You can see why she doesn't write for the National Review anymore. A real conservative website won't put up with the ignorant bias of an entertainer.

sotomayor
the woman is a racist pur and simple,

Happy Birthday Baracky!
Would you like to send Barack Obama a birthday message this year?

Now's your chance.

Though he has never released a long-form birth certificate, Obama claims to have been born Aug. 4, 1961, in an unnamed Honolulu hospital that has yet to take credit for the historic birth of the baby who would become America's first black president.

WND's SuperStore has designed and printed postcards for the occasion. The front of the card raises the question: "Where's the birth certificate?" The back is open for your personalized greetings.

"I'm encouraging Americans to send these postcards in plenty of time for Barack Obama's birthday," said Joseph Farah, editor and chief executive officer of WND and someone who has made it his personal mission to find that missing birth certificate. "This is an opportunity to anyone to send two messages at once to Obama – one concerning the search for truth about his constitutional eligibility for office and the second your own personalized note."

Farah points out the postcards can be used to send notes to anyone – not just Barack Obama.

"These postcards are not pre-addressed to the White House," he said. "They are postcards that can be used to send to your friends, your member of Congress, your relatives. It's just another way of keeping the issue of eligibility on the front burner – right up through 2012 if necessary."

Purchasers of the postcards will receive mailing addresses for the White House and Congress should they choose to use them for those purposes.

It's just the latest effort by Farah to raise the visibility of an issue he says was ignored by his colleagues in the media and most of the nation's elected officials, including Republicans.

Go here for more info on sending Baracky a B-Day greeting he won't forget:

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId= 102900

WHERE'S THE BIRTH CERTIFICATE?

USPatriot56


Ann gets it right again
Fantastic bashing by Ann of liberal judges, Sotomayor, and the whole scheme of law school testing and "meritocracy."

Thanks again Ann
Mistress of the understatement, Sotomayor is anything but brilliant. Racist yes, brilliant no. Crazier than Ginsberg yes, the feelings of a underpriviledged, poor family, I'm a victim type, yes. What ever happened to ruling on the Constitution and the nation's laws?

constitution of the Court
Among all this fretting about race & color I'm amused by the dance avoiding another aspect of the composition of SCOUS:

If & when Sotomayor is confirmed that will result in the high court of this predomianately Protestant nation to have a Catholic majority.

Is this good, bad, or does it not matter?

This observation is not an instance of Catholic bashing. For one thing, I am a (practicing) Catholic convert who once was Protestant.

Obama's Empirical Home Inspectors!!
As part of the Homeowners Destruction Bill, aka--Cap and Trade, or the latest thing the MSM is calling it, the Climate Bill, they included a section that would create a whole new Group of Government Brown Shirts whose job will be to Come To Your Home and Evalate it and Determine if you are even allowed to sell it. And, if they find that you do not meet their Green Standads to Save The Planet, you have to bring it up to their Standards, or They Will Condemn the Property, and now, not only can you not sell your home, They Will Not Even Allow you To Remain in Your Own Home, as it is Unsafe to You and The Planet.

Do even you Lib Trolls want a government that has this sort of control over your personal lives. If so, you folks need to be Committed To the Nearest Lock Up Mental Ward as soon as is possible, as you do not have the Sense to take care of yourself and are therefore a Threat To Yourself or Others, and as a public safety measure, you need to be removed from society, and also you need to be Neutered so that you Cannot Reproduce the Stupidity.

Thanks Retired Geek in Va
And, a Happy 4th of July to you and yours. God Bless America!! Stand up for freedom! Fight Socialism at every level of government, beginning in your hometown, county and state.

Socialism is like a Cancer. It starts out with a few Mutant Cells and grows and Spreads to infect the whole body. Look at the state of the union now!! We have a congress proposing that a whole new branch of government be formed to inspect your home before you can even sell it. This is part of the Cap and Tax Bill that the Nazis in the House of Representatives passed this last week.

It is time for Americans to Stand Up and Say Hell No to Obama and the Socialists now in charge of this great nation.

Celebrate Independence and Then Get Busy Defending IT By Fighting Obama and All the Socialists who are bound and determined to destroy this nation and our freedoms.

We must Stand As Soldiers, because this is the biggest fight we have had for our independence since The American Revolution against England. The King of England was never as Tyrannical as Is Obama this Current Congress Being Lead by Nazi Pelozi and Harry Adolph Reid, and Barney, the C.S. Frank and other deviants.

Discrimination
It's interesting that we have decided that Discrimination only applies if you happen to have the right skin color. Can one be a racist if they have a darker skin color or come from a Latina background then discriminate against whit males? Guess not.

July 4, 2009 Remember American Soldiers

History will record that the American Soldier and those American Soldiers who have fallen, rank in the greatest humans who have ever lived on this planet.

The American Soldier has set free millions in bondage and defended the freedom of America with willingness of the ultimate sacrifice.

The Fallen American Soldier is someone who walked the hero's path. Someone who walked into the heart of darkness for Duty, Honor and Country.

The American Soldier waits for the day that they have lived for and trained for their entire life - to defend until death, their families and America, its citizens and freedom.

The American soldier is the fiercest Warrior ever in history, because their mission is the defense of family, neighbors, America and freedom.

The families of the American Soldier, while their faces beamed with pride, their hearts were filled with anxiety and tears as they watched their American Soldier leave to defend them and this Great Country.

Families and neighbors look with horror as the military vehicle stops in front of the home of the American Soldier, to inform them of the ultimate sacrifice of their hero.

No honor can be too great; every tribute is too small for the Fallen American Soldier and their families.

God Bless the American Soldier and their families!

God have mercy on every American Soldier in our History who has made the ultimate Sacrifice in defense of this 'Great Nation' and setting Humans free all over the World.

July 4, 2009 Remember American Soldiers

History will record that the American Soldier and those American Soldiers who have fallen, rank in the greatest humans who have ever lived on this planet.

The American Soldier has set free millions in bondage and defended the freedom of America with willingness of the ultimate sacrifice.

The Fallen American Soldier is someone who walked the hero's path. Someone who walked into the heart of darkness for Duty, Honor and Country.

The American Soldier waits for the day that they have lived for and trained for their entire life - to defend until death, their families and America, its citizens and freedom.

The American soldier is the fiercest Warrior ever in history, because their mission is the defense of family, neighbors, America and freedom.

The families of the American Soldier, while their faces beamed with pride, their hearts were filled with anxiety and tears as they watched their American Soldier leave to defend them and this Great Country.

Families and neighbors look with horror as the military vehicle stops in front of the home of the American Soldier, to inform them of the ultimate sacrifice of their hero.

No honor can be too great; every tribute is too small for the Fallen American Soldier and their families.

God Bless the American Soldier and their families!

God have mercy on every American Soldier in our History who has made the ultimate Sacrifice in defense of this 'Great Nation' and setting Humans free all over the World.

Sharon in FL
You got the math right. I agree also the blood spilling is near apolitical, nonpartisan or bipartisan.
The blood is on all of us in our present culture of death including assisted suicides, pulling plugs in most questionable circumstances and euthanasia by self-appointed agents - medical providers who have chosen to take lives as serial murderers in most cases so far.
Ginsburg and her reaching for justification of murder for convenience of women, legislating from the bench started the bloodbath.
Obama advances it with his "above my pay grade" fecklessness and advocacy of putting live born babies out to die after botched abortions.
He has taught his daughters and others with his I don't want them punished by an unwanted pregnancy statement it is okay to have promiscuous, unwed sex like his mother did.
Disgusting! Disgusting as the euphemisms like fetus for a live baby in the pro-choicers scrabbling like animals to justify their heinuous crimes against humanity.
If it is okay for a woman to murder a little baby because it inconveniences her, after she made her choice to have unprotected sex with a man with whom she did not want to have a baby at the time, it must then by that logic be okay for anyone to murder anyone else who invonveniences them.
That is where we are today, on the precipice of degradation and Godlessness. God knows about this, has seen it before at least twice and took action to stop it. God will most assuredly do so again, perhaps already is in progress doing it based on international, national and local news headlines since Obama.
There has not been in my lifetime so far of three-score plus years such a deluge of unpleasant, even shocking news daily, several times updated in a 24-hour day.

dan
you whine"It doesn't make any sense ??? Even If Judge Sotomayor turns out to be a poor justice, (which I doubt), one supreme court judge cant "destroy America". Judging her record she has been a fairly moderate Judge. "

we peons dont get to vote for a supreme court justice, moron. you voted to destroy america when you voted for an anti-american leftist dictator loving racist to be the one making supreme court nominations. regarding the wise latina, whom you think will be such a wonderful addition to the scotus...surely somewhere there is a female hispanic affirmative action product who managed to graduate from a law school, who is NOT A RACIST. surely there is one candidate who is not a proven self proclaimed racist. if soto were a moderate, which she certainly is not, what is good about being a "moderate"? a good supreme court justice would